Andrew Davis, LMFT

Why you keep attracting the same relationship patterns (and how to change them)

Why you keep attracting the same relationship patterns (and how to change them), by Andrew Davis, LMFT

By Andrew Davis, LMFT — licensed marriage and family therapist specializing in trauma, narcissistic abuse recovery, and LGBTQ+ affirming care.

 

Many people come to therapy asking some version of the same question: why do I keep ending up in the same kind of relationship?

On the surface, the details may change. The person looks different. The circumstances are new. But over time, the dynamic starts to feel familiar in ways that are hard to ignore. If that’s been your experience, it’s not random. And it’s not because you’re missing something obvious.

Repeated relationship patterns tend to follow a logic, even when they feel frustrating or confusing. They’re often shaped by earlier experiences, attachment patterns, and ways you learned to stay connected or cope.

Understanding that pattern is where real change starts.

Why relationship patterns repeat even when you’re trying to choose differently

Relationship patterns are rarely random. We tend to feel drawn to what is familiar, not necessarily what is healthy.

If you grew up in an environment where love was inconsistent, conditional, or required emotional effort to maintain, your nervous system may have learned to associate intensity, instability, or self-sacrifice with connection.

Over time, that can shape who you feel drawn to and how you show up in relationships.

This might look like:

  • Being drawn to emotionally unavailable partners
  • Taking responsibility for other people’s emotions
  • Prioritizing others’ needs while minimizing your own
  • Confusing caretaking, fixing, or rescuing with love

These patterns weren’t random choices. They were adaptations that once helped you stay connected or cope.

Hi, I'm Andrew. If you've ever asked yourself why you keep ending up in the same kind of relationship, you're not alone and you're not broken. These patterns make sense when you understand where they come from. I help people untangle exactly this, in a space that's honest, compassionate, and focused on real change. If you're ready to explore what's possible, I'd love to connect.

Awareness alone isn’t always enough

Many people understand their patterns and still find themselves repeating them. That’s because these patterns don’t exist only in your thoughts. They’re also shaped by your body and nervous system.

Insight can help you see what’s happening, but it doesn’t automatically change how you respond in the moment.

Real change usually involves practicing something different, especially in situations that would have triggered the old pattern.

Over time, that can include:

  • Learning to tolerate emotional safety without feeling restless or anxious
  • Rebuilding and maintaining boundaries
  • Responding differently to familiar triggers
  • Trusting your own perceptions and needs

This is where therapy can make a meaningful difference.

Why certain people feel familiar, even when they aren’t good for you

Early relationships shape what closeness feels like in your body. If love felt unpredictable, dismissive, or unsafe, steady and consistent connection can feel unfamiliar at first.

That doesn’t mean something is wrong. It means your system learned to recognize a certain kind of dynamic as “normal.”

Because of that, you may find yourself drawn to people or situations that recreate a similar emotional experience, even if it isn’t what you consciously want.

Changing this isn’t about forcing yourself to choose differently. It involves shifting the internal patterns that shape attraction, expectations, and how you respond in relationships.

What it looks like when you respond differently in your relationships

Changing relationship patterns usually doesn’t happen all at once. It starts with noticing them more clearly, especially in the moments when they’re actively playing out.

Instead of reacting automatically, you begin to recognize what’s happening in real time, in your thoughts, your body, and your impulses. That creates space to respond differently, even if only slightly at first.

Over time, those small shifts begin to add up.

You might notice:

  • Less tolerance for emotional inconsistency
  • Greater clarity about your needs and limits
  • A stronger sense of self-trust in how you interpret situations
  • Feeling drawn to more reciprocal, emotionally available relationships

This isn’t about getting it right every time. It’s about gradually responding in ways that are more aligned with what you actually want in a relationship.

If you’re ready for something different

Therapy offers a space to explore your relationship patterns without blame or judgment. Instead of trying to force change, the work is about understanding what’s driving these patterns and gradually responding differently over time.

You don’t have to figure all of this out on your own. Having a place to slow things down and look at what’s actually happening can make the process feel more manageable and more clear.

If you’re considering therapy, a conversation can help you get a sense of whether this approach feels like the right fit for you.

By Andrew Davis, LMFT.

Andrew is a licensed marriage and family therapist with a master’s degree in clinical psychology from Antioch University Los Angeles. He has been practicing since 2018 and is licensed in California, Florida, Oregon, Arizona, and Nevada.

His clinical work focuses on trauma, narcissistic abuse recovery, relationship concerns, and LGBTQ+ affirming therapy. He uses evidence-based approaches including CBT, DBT, mindfulness, and creative arts interventions.
Andrew Davis, LMFT

About the author

Andrew Davis, LMFT, is a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist specializing in narcissistic abuse recovery, relational trauma, codependency, and burnout in high-achieving adults. He offers private-pay online therapy in California, Arizona, Florida, Nevada, and Oregon. Licensed in CA (#126415), AZ (#LMFT-16251), NV (#4999-R), and OR (#T2811); Florida telehealth registration #TPMF1051. More about Andrew